​Consumer Reports Disses Toyota Prius C

Author: John LesterBy:
Staff Reporter
May. 20, 2014

The latest Consumer Reports review for the Toyota Prius C is devastating to the automaker, but it sparked some controversy because they advised potential buyers to find a used regular Prius over the new hybrid vehicle.

The Prius C a less-than-stellar overall rating of 53, setting it near the bottom of its class.

It was this negative review that prompted the people over at Cars.com to intervene. Although Cars.com recognizes that everyone is entitled to their own opinion, the automotive review site wrote, “We have to step in and let car shoppers know we have a different point of view that could impact the car they decide to buy.”

Despite Consumer Reports’ disappointing test scores, Cars.com had an entirely different impression of the compact full-hybrid vehicle. According to Cars.com, “If value proposition were the 2012 Toyota Prius c’s only feat, it would likely still be a sales success, but the mini-Prius is also surprisingly roomy — and has a comfortable ride and an impressive array of standard features.”

Cars.com also contends that the vehicle’s price is reasonable, in spite of Consumer Report’s contention that it is too expensive. Cars.com argues that the Prius C base model, which is $19,710, is very well equipped and is competitively priced versus other subcompacts. In fact, the Prius c bested every vehicle in its class except the Nissan Versa when taking the cost of fuel into account. The Prius C also surpasses the Chevy Sonic and Honda Insight in affordability, even after adding an extra $950 for the Two trim level.

As for Consumer Report’s assertion that consumers should opt for a used Prius liftback instead of a new Prius C, Cars.com couldn’t disagree more. “While we might pick the Prius C over even a new Prius, used prices for the liftback are higher today than at any time in the past six months, according to Cars.com’s inventory. This makes it a bad time to buy one on the used market.”

Share this article